Australian Traveller

  • Home
    • News
    • Travel Deals
  • Destinations
    • ACT
      • Canberra
    • NSW
      • Sydney
      • Batemans Bay
      • Broken Hill
      • Byron Bay
      • Coffs Harbour
      • Dubbo
      • Katoomba
      • Merimbula
      • Newcastle
      • Orange
      • Port Macquarie
      • Port Stephens
      • Tamworth
      • Thredbo
      • Wagga Wagga
      • Wollongong
    • NT
      • Alice Springs
      • Darwin
      • Kakadu
    • QLD
      • Brisbane
      • Cairns
      • Fraser Island
      • Gold Coast
      • Noosa
      • Port Douglas
      • Townsville
      • The Whitsundays
    • SA
      • Adelaide
      • Clare Valley
      • Coober Pedy
      • Port Lincoln
      • Victor Harbor
    • TAS
      • Hobart
      • Launceston
      • Burnie
    • VIC
      • Melbourne
      • Ballarat
      • Daylesford & Hepburn Springs
      • Geelong
      • Mildura
      • Mornington Peninsula
      • Warrnambool
      • Yarra Valley
    • WA
      • Perth
      • Albany
      • Broome
      • Coral Bay
      • Esperance
    • 100 Best Towns in Australia
    • 100 Best Views In Australia
  • Experiences
    • 100 Things to Do Before you Die
    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets of Australia
    • Adventure Holidays
    • Affordable Holidays
    • Beach Holidays
    • Camping Holidays
    • Driving Holidays
    • 4WD Holidays
    • Family Holidays
    • Food & Wine
      • 100 Greatest Australian Gourmet Experiences
      • High Tea
    • Hiking and Biking
    • Island Holidays
    • Luxury Escapes
    • Outback Holidays
    • Romantic Getaways
    • 100 Things To Do In Australia You’ve Never Heard Of
  • Accommodation
    • Brands
      • Accor
      • Art Series Hotels
      • Crown
      • Delaware North
      • Hyatt
      • Medina
      • Majestic Hotels
      • Sofitel
      • Spicers
      • Starwood
      • Travelodge
      • Voyages
    • Brisbane
    • Canberra
    • Cairns
    • Gold Coast
    • Hobart
    • Holiday Homes
    • Melbourne
      • Budget
      • Boutique
      • Luxury
    • Perth
    • Port Douglas
    • Sydney
      • Budget
      • Boutique
      • Luxury
  • Our Favourites
  • Tech & Style
    • Photography
  • Readers
    • Celebrity
    • Reader Stories
    • Your Shot: Winner
    • Your Shot: Runners Up
  • Shop
  • Opinions
    • The Long Way Round
    • The Disgruntled Traveller
    • Editor, Unedited
    • Be Our Guest
    • Trip Notes
    • The Wanderer
    • The Wheelie Traveller
Home > Melbourne > The Lyall Hotel

The Lyall Hotel

Bedroom - Standard Room at The Lyall.

Bedroom - Standard Room at The Lyall.

Bedroom - Standard Room at The Lyall

Bedroom - Standard Room at The Lyall

Interior of One Bedroom Suite at The Lyall

Interior of One Bedroom Suite at The Lyall

Exterior of The Lyall Hotel at dusk.

Exterior of The Lyall Hotel at dusk.

The cozy downstairs bar at The Lyall.

The cozy downstairs bar at The Lyall.

Featured Image The Lyall Hotel Review
  • Bedroom - Standard Room at The Lyall.
  • Bedroom - Standard Room at The Lyall
  • Interior of One Bedroom Suite at The Lyall
  • Exterior of The Lyall Hotel at dusk.
  • The cozy downstairs bar at The Lyall.
  • Featured Image The Lyall Hotel Review

Georgia Rickard checks in at one of Melbourne’s lesser-known hotels… But is it an undiscovered gem, or a nightmare stay?  “So where are you staying?” asks a Melbourne-based friend, when I announce my impending arrival in her town.

“The Lyall,” I reply triumphantly, “in South Yarra.” It’s one of Melbourne’s best, its website reckons, and I’ve been looking forward to gloating about it for a while. But she remains silent.

“In South Yarra?” she finally asks, confused. “That’s where I live. I’ve never heard of it.”

Oh.

When two more Melburnian mates give me the same response, I start feeling nervous. What kind of five-star hotel – in one of Melbourne’s poshest suburbs, no less – is unheard of by the locals? And more importantly, have I made a really bad choice?

The front of the building does nothing to ease my mind. Its exterior – an elegant, understated cream framed by black wrought iron and lushly green trees – gives away almost nothing. Aside from two small signs announcing The Lyall Hotel and Spa’s existence, you’d never even know it was there. I step inside feeling slightly apprehensive. This could be bad.

Thankfully, though, it isn’t. Actually, it’s a different world in here. Sleek, softly lit surfaces. Original artworks on every wall. The corridors are wide, carpeted highways; the lighting is gentle and flattering… The Lyall has the look and feel of a much bigger hotel, despite its boutique offering of just 40 suites. Everything feels, well, plush. Walking around, I take it all in with a triumphant thought: I’ve scored! But one half-formed suspicion still lingers: how come I’ve never heard of this place before? Why doesn’t the whole world know about it?
Nathan the concierge knows why. “We don’t really advertise,” he says with a half-smile and a shrug. “We just don’t need to.” The Lyall has a dedicated cult following, he tells me – most of its business comes from word of mouth.

I soon see why. When I’m shown around my room – a standard one-bedroom suite with small balcony – the staff member goes out of his way to point out useful features (light switches, the wi-fi password and so on) before quietly showing himself out.

Admittedly, the room has a slightly dated feel thanks to some older-style fittings (the lights in the bathroom, the style of some furnishings, and the balcony door latch – it’s just that, an old metal latch), and I’m disappointed by the small bathtub. Where’s the oversized spa? But flat-screen TVs (two of ’em), black marble benchtops, dual shower heads, heated bathroom floors, a timeless, muted colour scheme: these things help make up for it. As do in-room white orchids. And the fabulous service.

Ah, the service. This, I soon realise, is The Lyall’s signature difference, and the reason why so many have committed to a long-term love affair with this place. Nathan memorises my name within seconds of my arrival, and greets me personally each time I wander by the lobby. At one point, dazed and confused after a massage, I stumble through the hotel doors and confess that I’m so relaxed, I can’t be bothered to go and collect my car, which I’ve abandoned a couple of blocks away. My in-room phone is ringing by the time I’ve returned to my suite. “Would you like us to collect your car for you, ma’am?” comes the question. Not bad.

When I rise from a nap later on, I discover a handwritten note slipped under my door. It explains that my car has been collected, my keys are with the front desk and, as requested, my laptop has been retrieved from the front seat and is awaiting collection. They would have delivered it to me already, the note adds, but they knew I was planning a nap and didn’t wish to disturb my sleep.

Later that evening, I’m getting ready for dinner and drinks on nearby Chapel Street when my doorbell chimes. “Would you like your bed turned down this evening?” asks yet another polite staff member. I decline his offer, but close the door feeling slightly thrilled. This is a hotel for real grown- ups, I decide. It takes an enormous amount of control to resist jumping gleefully up and down on the bed.

Then, wonder of wonders, I take a wander round the hotel. And that’s when it happens: I fall in love. You can practically hear my heart break as I uncover the wide couches, the heavy coffee table; the roaring, crackling fireplace. This cosy little nook, quietly tucked away on my floor, is my ultimate Saturday night in. It’s practically calling out for me to skip dinner and come curl up with a book.

I’m actually wondering how I can cut dinner short and return to my new-found nirvana when I discover something even better: there’s a fireplace-and-couches nook like this one on every single floor. I can’t cope. I literally cannot. I do the only thing I can right now: call my mum.

Aside from leaving, the only real downside comes when I attempt to book into the spa. It’s a space of airy, floor-to-ceiling whiteness – which, as everyone knows, is the international guarantee of an excellent spa experience – and after agonising over the menu and finally deciding on a Payot Perfect Experience facial, I discover it’s completely booked out for the weekend. Devastating.

Grumpily, I flop on the spa’s couch and watch the steady stream of well-dressed women flowing in and out the spa doors. Who are these people? I think to myself, outraged. And more importantly, what are they doing in my hotel?
That’s when I make a decision; then and there. I’m not telling anyone else about The Lyall – no way. Not unless they’re taking me back with them.


The Details

Where //  14 Murphy St, South Yarra. This pretty, tree-lined side street is a five-minute walk from Melbourne’s smart South Yarra shopping and dining district.
Notes // Take the kids elsewhere – they won’t mix well with the sophisticated atmosphere and expensive artworks. And pre-book your spa treatments!
Contact // (03) 9868 8222; thelyall.com

THE GOSSIP
“For almost a decade The Lyall Hotel has been a byword for Melbourne luxury, and this remains the case.” – thetelegraph.co.uk
THE AT VERDICT
Georgia Rickard, who paid her own way and visited anonymously, says:
“I’ve stayed in more ‘stylish’ rooms, but The Lyall is all substance. Timeless, elegant – perfect for a low-key luxe weekend.”

Tweet

COMMENTS

LEAVE A REPLY Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

*

LOCATION

View on map

Lyall Hotel

THE DETAILS

Where // ACT, Australia

at cover _45 small print

BUY THE ISSUE

This article appeared in Issue 45 of Australian Traveller.

    The JUN/JUL Road Trips & Short Breaks Edition
* 20 Short Breaks - State By State coverage of ultimate weekenders
* Quick Day Getaways - Escape the daily grind and hit the road less travelled for one-day sightseeing drives.
* Which Cruise? - Plus step aboard with AT as it hits the decks of three luxury vessels
Plus

High (Socie)Tea
Fremantle in WA
Airlie Beach
Sydney to Melbourne: Coastal Hugging

BUY THIS ISSUE

RELATED ARTICLES

REVIEW: THE CONTEMPORARY, DARLINGHURST - HOW TASTY IS THE 'TASTEMAKER'S' NEW HANDIWORK?

The Contemporary, Darlinghurst, by Geoff Clark

No lobby, no room service, no valet parking – Alissa Jenkins finds out if this discreet abode upholds its designer reputation.  This...

THREE CHIC CENTRAL PERTH HOTELS WITHOUT THE STING

Rendezvous Hotel, Perth Central

Save your Perth dollars for getting out and about. These heart-of-the-city hotels have everything you need for a bargain price. Parmelia Hilton...

MANLY'S Q STATION BRIMS WITH HISTORY AND A FEW WHEELIE HICCUPS

The leafy city views of Sydney from Manly's Q Station.

I had high hopes for my overnight stay at Manly's Q Station boutique hotel in Sydney Harbour National Park. Just 30 minutes...

MORE FROM MELBOURNE

CHEESE TO PLEASE: FOUR FAB FROMAGERIES IN MELBOURNE

Richmond Hill Cafe & Larder, Melbourne

Upmarket cheese is the main course in these fabulous Melbourne eateries. Richmond Hill Café & Larder Cool, old school fromagerie harbouring ‘barnyardy’...

REVIEW: MILK THE COW, LICENSED FROMAGERIE, MELBOURNE

Cheese and wine tasting: Milk The Cow, Melbourne

Surely, asks Margaret Barca, food-mad Melbourne is the only city where a late night, licensed cheese shop would not just be considered......

THE VIEW: OLSEN PENTHOUSE, MELBOURNE

Spa-tacular view: The Olsen Penthouse, South Yarra, Melbourne

Fancy a stunning view across Melbourne's city skyline from the comfort of your own spa? Try Olsen Penthouse then; Justin Bieber did....

SUBSCRIBE

Back issues available
ORDER NOW
Australian Traveller April/May Issue

OUR MONTHLY NEWSLETTER

FOLLOW US

australian traveller facebook link australian traveller twitter link australian traveller rss link Follow us on Google+ Follow us on Pinterest

LATEST ON FACEBOOK

LATEST TWEETS

Tweets by @AustTraveller

WHERE ARE YOU TRAVELLING TO?

Select a state to view more

  • NSW

    • NSW: Country house escapes for groups
    • The South Coast. A Gourmet Treasure Trail.
    • Gulargambone: the middle of nowhere
    • Old Grafton to Glenn Innes Road
    • Slow Road Over the Blue Mountains
  • WA

    • Western Australia: Country house escapes for groups
    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets #56 Point Samson, WA
    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets #70 Depuch Island, WA
    • Beached in Esperance
    • The Tin Horse Highway, Western Australia
  • QLD

    • Queensland: Country house escapes for groups
    • 2012 Readers’ Choice Awards: Favourite Winter Destination
    • Don’t You Wish You Were Here?
    • Culinary Queensland Train Trip
    • Whitsunday Wind Power
  • VIC

    • Victoria: Country house escapes for groups
    • Back roads through the goldfields, Victoria
    • The Kilns
    • 100 Best Views In Australia #5 Craig’s Hut, Mt Stirling, VIC
    • Beautiful Beechworth
  • TAS

    • Tasmania: Country house escapes for groups
    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets #64 Arthur River, Tas
    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets #71 Evandale, Tas
    • Best beach retreats from under $200 – Three Hummock Island
    • Mountain Valley Retreat – Haven for Humans and Devils
  • ACT

    • Gourmet Treasure Trails: The Poacher’s Way
    • 104 Things To Do This Summer: ACT
    • ACT & Surrounds- 2011 Regional Food Report
    • Affordable Summer Holidays: Canberra
    • Cultural Dreaming; Profile of the New Indidenous Gallery at the NGA’s curator
  • NT

    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets #44 MacDonnell Ranges, NT
    • Litchfield National Park, Northern Territory
    • Wish You Were Here: Gunlom Falls Top Pool
    • Reader Stories: Lost at Litchfield
    • 100 Best Views In Australia #15 Ormiston Gorge, NT
  • SA

    • South Australia: Country house escapes for groups
    • 100 Incredible Travel Secrets #54 Innamincka Hotel, SA
    • Fleurieu Peninsula, South Australia
    • Nullarbor Links, SA & WA
    • The Nullarbor Links, SA/WA
  • © 2012 Australian Traveller
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Privacy
  • Back issues
  • Subscribe
  • subscribe to at wire
  • Update subscription details